A new fundamentalism has arrived on the scene in the evangelical world. It’s kinda like legacy fundamentalism, but also kinda not. I believe the various evangelical scenes are on the precipice of a newer fundamentalist-modernist split. In this video essay, I review components of generic, faithful Christianity, define and give examples of second-stage legacy Baptist fundamentalism, then make some observations of and connections to the 2022 evangelical scene.
If you don’t want to watch the video, you can find the notes from my discussion here. They include a bit more nuance than what I managed to convey in the video.
- 0:00 – 00:45: Introduction
- 00:45 – 03:57: Generic, bible-believing Christianity. The “Stackhouse hexagon”
- 03:57 – 11:32: Brief survey of second-stage, “legacy fundamentalism”
- 11:32 – 14:52: Introducing “fundamentalistic evangelicals”
- 14:53 – 21:27: Pressures that have created this new fundamentalism
- 21:28 – 26:07: Hamilton’s “political quadrilateral” and its implications
- 26:08 – 28:07: The shifted battlespace for fundamentalism compared to 1920
- 28:08 – 35:56: Observations about this new fundamentalism
- 35:57 – 43:26: Sketching part of the new fundamentalist landscape
- 43:27 – 45:23: A “convergence” between elements of legacy fundamentalism and the new?
- 45:24 – 51:03: Why you should care
For the podcast version of this video, see here. The song “The Proof of Your Love” (by For King & Country) captures my fears about the danger of a militant ethos coloring the Christian faith—where is the love of Christ?